How to be a good follower… when your manager makes you do stuff you don’t want to do.
Work Disagreements? Finding Common Ground When You See Things Differently
Work can get tricky. Sometimes, your brilliant idea and your manager's, well, less brilliant idea, bump heads. Before you march into a heavyweight office showdown (not a great look!), here's how to navigate that disagreement like a workplace diplomat.
First Things First: Be a Team Player, Not a Follower
Being a valuable teammate is essential. We all know that reliable co-worker who crushes deadlines and keeps the mood upbeat. But what if a "reliable rockstar" turns into a "frustrated robot" stuck on a seemingly pointless task?
That's where thinking for yourself comes in. Don't just blindly follow orders. Put on your detective hat: figure out the bigger picture behind the task. Your manager may have a long-term plan or a hidden reason for this seemingly dull task or assignment.
Disagreeing Doesn't Have to Be Disastrous: Finding Your Voice (The Dos and Don'ts)
So, you've unravelled the "why", and it's still puzzling? Here's how to voice your opinion like a pro:
Do:
Request a private meeting: Let them know you want to do your best work and that their insights are valuable. Ask your manager to explain their “why”, and their perspective.
Actively listen: There might be a key detail you missed.
Ask if you can suggest an alternative: Describe the proposed process/approach. Focus on the benefits – how your idea saves time, boosts efficiency, or improves the job.
Maintain professionalism: If your manager declines your suggestion, complete the task with a professional attitude.
Have a follow-up chat: Discuss what worked well and what could be improved for future situations.
Don't:
Blindly follow orders: Understand the "why" behind the task.
Launch into a public argument: Keep it professional and respectful.
Focus on negativity: Focus on the good aspects of your job and maintain a positive demeanour.
Ignore the decision: Respect your manager's choice, even if you disagree.
Give up easily: If your concerns are major, explore your options (see below).
Go straight to senior management: Unless the situation is urgent or severe, resolve it with your manager first. This shows respect for their authority and allows them to address your concerns.
Remember, You're More Than Just a Task: Picking Your Battles
Not every disagreement needs a full-on debate. Completing the task might be the best approach if it's a minor issue.
Bonus Tip: Positivity is your secret weapon! A negative attitude can make even the most minor task feel like a mountain. Focus on the good aspects of your job and maintain a professional demeanour.
Still Stuck? Exploring Your Options
If you've followed these steps and still have significant concerns, here are some next moves:
Seek Guidance: Talk to a trusted colleague or HR for another perspective.
Upskill and Move On: If these types of tasks constantly impede your career goals, explore new opportunities within the company or elsewhere that better suit your skills.
Being a good team player also means advocating for yourself and your career. So, the next time your ideas clash with your manager's, remember there's a way to find common ground while keeping your voice heard (and your sanity intact).
A Case Study
David, a meticulous data analyst, thrived on untangling complex datasets. However, administrative tasks constantly snagged his workflow, like the current mind-numbing job of manually entering employee contact information into a new HR system. It felt like a waste of his analytical skills and, quite frankly, beneath him - something to be done by an administrator, not an analyst.
Understanding the "Why" (and the Resistance)
Determined to free up his time, David met with his manager, Lisa. He expressed his enthusiasm for data analysis and desire to maximise his impact. He then inquired about the new HR system and the manual data entry.
Lisa explained the system was new and integration with their existing database wasn't a priority. She saw manual entry as a necessary evil, a small price for a new system. David listened, but a flicker of resistance sparked in him.
Offering a Different Perspective (Twice)
"I understand," David said. "But wouldn't automating the data transfer save countless hours in the long run? I could research the feasibility and propose a plan."
Lisa, however, remained unconvinced. "It's a good idea, David, but we have tight deadlines on other projects. Manual entry might not be ideal, but it's the quickest solution for now."
Persistence Pays Off
David wasn't ready to give up. He believed in the efficiency gains automation could bring. "With your permission," he pressed politely, "I could dedicate a few hours after work to research this. It might be a simpler process than we think."
Lisa, impressed by David's persistence and willingness to go the extra mile, finally relented. "Alright, David. Look into it. But remember, manual entry is still the priority for now."
Finding Common Ground (Eventually)
David tackled the manual data entry with a positive attitude. He knew it was temporary and listened to podcasts or audiobooks while he worked to keep his mind stimulated. He even created a system to make the data entry more efficient. In the evenings, he delved into researching the data transfer options. He presented his findings to Lisa, outlining a step-by-step plan, potential risks, and significant time savings. This time, his well-researched proposal swayed Lisa. She greenlit the data transfer project and assigned David to oversee it, impressed by his initiative and positive attitude.
The Outcome
David's proactive approach paid off. The successful data transfer freed him and his colleagues from tedious tasks, allowing them to focus on their core strengths. David improved efficiency, showcased his problem-solving skills, and earned his manager's respect. He continued to excel in his analytical role, contributing significantly to the company's success, all thanks to his persistence in the face of initial resistance and his ability to maintain a positive attitude.
Book a free consultation and we can work together to coach you through any challenging situation in the workplace.
